Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

[rcarca]

These were taken on the same visit from across the river:


2Y2A3343 by RCARCARCA, on Flickr

EXIF: 5Diii, 24-105mm at 105mm, ISO 1000, 1/250, f6.3


7D__0136 by RCARCARCA, on Flickr

EXIF: 7D, 70-300mm DO at 70mm, ISO 1000, 1/500, f6.3

Interested in comments...

Thanks

Richard

[Muscat]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

It may be the PP but the first image seems to have more detail and better colour

[rcarca]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

It may be the PP but the first image seems to have more detail and better colour

That was my take as well. Same time (within reason) but quite a difference in detail. Maybe just a softer lens with the 70-300mm DO lens. I am not brilliantly happy with the DO and will move to the L when funds allow... Maybe I can trade in my DO plus my 15-85mm from my 7D, then keep the 70 - 300 L on the 7D, with the 24-105 on the 5Diii...

Just dreaming!

Richard

[Nathaniel]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

The first image for me too. More definition and better colours.

[rajjayaraj]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

Could this be down to camera than the lens?
Raj

[rcarca]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

Could this be down to camera than the lens?
Raj

Good question... I don't absolutely know, but I can have crystal sharp photographs from my 7D.

R

[tesarver]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

1st image for me as well.

Tom

[David Morison]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

Lovely looking church. First is definitely the best but the second on my monitor is overexposed destroying some fine detail. With two totally different classes of lens and different exposure or PP this isn't really a valid comparison.

David

[Judder Man]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

Agree, the 2nd image is 1/2 a stop over exposed., its difficult to judge on the difference in sharpness, clarity, definition on 2 different lenses. Was the focus point the same for both images.

[Muscat]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

Rcarca, can you repeat the experiment by taking a common shot with both cameras and each using both lenses, yes you will have 4 images to compare but you cuold compare IQ of each lens on each camera to determine if it is the DO lens that is soft. Yes there will be different sizes of the landscape as one sensor is FF and the other a crop but the test I feel would still serve to tell you where the best quality can be found.

[rcarca]

Re: Bisham Church 5Diii v 7D

Thanks everyone for looking. I agree there is nothing here that is more than anecdotal. I will have to set up a better experiment! Perhaps in better light.

R